Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce  (2024)

Published: · Modified: by Christina Jolam · This post may contain affiliate links. See end of article for more information. · Leave a Comment

Jump to Recipe·Leave a Review

Here's all the tips and tricks you need to make stone crab claws for serving a mouth-watering crab claw hors d'oeuvres tray or dinner party platter at home. Grab your mallets and bibs and let's get this party started!

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce (1)

Can I tell you a secret? If you're the proud owner of Florida stone crab claws (or Jonah claws, or brown crab claws), they're most likely already cooked. That's right, the sweet, delicate meat inside of the shell you're staring down is ready to eat.

As a rule, the crabs and crab claws are steamed just after catching, because it helps the meat separate from the shell and gives us all an easier time getting them out of the shell.

You can find recipes for heating already-cooked stone crab claws, but serving crab claws chilled and dipped in creamy mustard is an excellent way - dare I say the very best way- to enjoy the coveted tender meat of the crab.

Ingredients for this recipe:

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce (2)

Before we get to the step by step directions, a few notes about the ingredients:

Crab claws: I used brown crab claws for this recipe, because they are readily available in Portugal. Stone crab claws or Jonah crab claws are other great options.

Dijon mustard: Dijon adds the perfect creamy, slightly spicy flavor to the sauce. Substitute 2 teaspoons dry mustard for 2 tablespoons Dijon, if needed.

Worcestershire sauce: this classic sauce adds rich umami to our creamy mustard. If you need a substitute, grab your favorite steak sauce, soy sauce or balsamic vinegar.

Full ingredient list and measurements included in the printable recipe card below.

Step by step instructions:

1. Make mustard sauce

Begin by making the creamy garlic mustard sauce. Combine mayo, grated garlic, Dijon, Worcestershire, lemon juice and hot sauce in a small mixing bowl. Taste and add salt and pepper. Once the flavor is just what you're looking for, refrigerate until serving. Keep in mind the garlic will continue to develop!

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce (3)

2. Prep crab claws

Prepare claws for serving by cleaning the shells under cold running water. Pile on a tray or platter and serve with creamy mustard sauce and lemons, along with a mallet or cracker at each plate. To open chilled crab claws, wrap a claw in a tea towel and use a wooden mallet (or back of a large spoon) to crack the shell in multiple places.

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce (4)

This will allow you to remove the shell without breaking up the claw meat or creating tiny shell fragments.

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce (5)

3. Serve and enjoy

Serve crab claws chilled on a platter with creamy garlic mustard sauce, lemon wedges and chives for garnish.

Looking for more crab recipes?

  • King Crab Legs with Lemon Garlic Butter
  • Broiled Crab Cakes (no filler!)
  • Crab-stuffed Shrimp Casserole
  • Shrimp and Crab-stuffed Salmon

FAQ's and Serving Suggestions:

What are stone crab claws?

Stone crab claws are the claws of the stone crab, a type of crab found in the western Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico. They have large, meaty claws, which are considered a delicacy.

How many stone crab claws are in a pound?

Florida crab claws come in a variety of sizes, so the number of claws per pound will vary. As a rule, medium claws offer 7-8 claws per pound, large claws will give you 4-5 claws per pound and you'll get three jumbo claws per pound.

How many crab claws per person?

For a main course, plan on 1-1 ½ pounds of crab claws per person, which will yield 3-5 ounces of crab meat. For an appetizer course, about ¾ of a pound should do the trick.

How to cook stone crab claws?

After catching the crab, claws are boiled or steamed, then chilled. Serve the meat cold with a creamy mustard dipping sauce.

Are stone crab claws available year-round?

No, stone crab claws are not available year-round. The harvesting season typically runs from October to May, with the peak availability in the winter months.

When is stone crab season?

If you're looking for Florida stone crabs, stone crab season runs from October to May in the United States. Jonah Crabs are a great alternative to fresh stone crab claws, and less pricey. While stone crabs in the US are mostly found in Florida, the Gulf Coast region and up to Georgia, Jonah crabs hang out in the Atlantic from North Carolina up to Maine.

In Portugal, gorgeous brown crabs (pictured in this recipe) can be purchased year round, but the main fishing season is July through November.

Remember, the availability of crab claws will vary depending on your location and the season, so it's always best to check with your local seafood market for the best options for your dinner party or date night at home!

How to crack stone crab claws?

Cracking stone crab claws can be a bit challenging, but with the right technique and tools, you can enjoy the delicious crab meat inside with minimal headache getting through those hard shells. Here's my best tips on the how to crack crab claws:

- A mallet is a good option, when applied with gentle force. For stone crabs, you can find industrial crab crackers that will help get through those tough shells with ease.
- My setup involves a wooden mallet and a dish towel, which protects my hands from any shell fragments or sharp edges, and helps soak up any liquid.
- The goal is to whack the shell firmly, but without shattering the claw shell, which creates tiny shards that are difficult to pick out of the meat. So hit the claw until cracked, then after you hear the crack,pull apart the shell to access the claw meat.

What to serve with crab claws?

I think of a crab claw dinner like I do a lobster dinner and pair it with Baked Fries and Savory Slaw or go upscale with Au Gratin Potatoes and Mediterranean Tossed Salad. Check out my 16 Best Side Dishes to Serve with Crab Claws next!

How to store crab claws?

Keep your cooked crab claws in the coldest part of your refrigerator and use within 2 days of purchase.

How long does cooked crab last in the refrigerator?

Refrigerate crab quickly after cooking and it will last in the coldest part of the refrigerator for 3-4 days.

Print

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce (8)

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce

5 Stars4 Stars3 Stars2 Stars1 Star

No reviews

  • Author: Christina Jolam
  • Total Time: 15 minutes
  • Yield: 4 (appetizer) 1x
Print Recipe

Ingredients

Scale

3 pounds crab claws

½ cup mayonnaise

1 large garlic clove, grated

2 tablespoons Dijon mustard

1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce

1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice, plus wedges, for serving

2 teaspoons hot sauce

Chives, diced for garnish

Pinch of salt and black pepper

Instructions

  1. Begin by making the creamy garlic mustard sauce. Combine mayo, grated garlic, Dijon, Worcestershire, lemon juice and hot sauce in a small mixing bowl. Taste and add salt and pepper. Refrigerate until serving (the garlic will continue to develop!)
  2. Prepare claws for serving by cleaning the shells under cold running water.To serve chilled crab claws, wrap a claw in a tea towel and use a wooden mallet (or back of a large spoon) to crack the shell in multiple places. This will allow you to remove the shell without breaking up the claw meat. Repeat with all claws.
  3. Serve over ice or chilled on a platter with lemon wedges and chives for garnish.

Notes

Use stone crab if you can find them! Jonah crab claws or brown crab claws are great options, as well.

  • Prep Time: 15
  • Category: Easy Recipes
  • Method: No Cook
  • Cuisine: American

More Recipes

  • Seasoned Baked Tilapia Recipe
  • Baked Tilapia with Creamy Lemon Butter Sauce
  • Pimento Cheese Shrimp Toast Appetizer
  • How to Make Perfect Salmon at Home

About Christina Jolam

Christina Jolam is a fish-forward recipe developer, photographer, and food writer. She creates easy and impressive seafood-focused recipes that home chefs of all levels can make and share. Her recipes and seafood expertise have been featured on CNNHealth, MSN, Pip and Ebby, Savoring the Good, Eat Blog Talk and more. She spends most of her time in a seaside village in Portugal with her adventure-loving husband, Ramesh.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

Crab Claws with Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce  (2024)

FAQs

Do you rinse crab claws before cooking? ›

You should rinse the stone crab claws under cold running water. This is done after carefully unwrapping them from the bags. Allow the stone crab claws to dry for 10-15 minutes, and place them in a large bowl. Add some cold water and ice cubes to the bowl, or place the bowl in the refrigerator for an hour.

What do you serve with crab claws? ›

Here are a handful of the best crab side dishes:
  • Steamed Artichokes with Garlic and Butter.
  • Cottage-Cut French Fries.
  • Roasted Brussels Sprouts.
  • Lemon and Garlic Butter Dipping Sauce.
  • Brandy-Infused Mayonnaise Dip.
  • Twice-Baked Garlic Mashed Potatoes.
  • Zucchini, Onion and Corn Hash.
  • Almond Caesar Salad.
Sep 8, 2022

What is the best way to eat crab claws? ›

How To Eat Stone Crab
  1. Boil your crab claw. ...
  2. Let it cool — it's best served cold!
  3. You need to crack into your stone crab claw shell. ...
  4. Flip your stone crab claw over and hit it a further three times.
  5. Remove the meat. ...
  6. Hold your crab claw by the pincer and dip into a delicious sauce — we'd recommend homemade mustard sauce.
Feb 20, 2024

What kind of butter is best for crab legs? ›

Clarified Butter - Pacific Seafood.

Is it better to steam or boil crab claws? ›

Jumbo and lump boast a flaky texture, while the claw exhibits a slightly fibrous feel. Boiling detracts from these differences with the excess moisture. Another win for “steamed crabs.” Go ahead and take the taste test, but first give your Jumbos a Traditional Maryland Steaming.

How long does it take to cook crab claws? ›

If you are able to get fresh crab claws, you will need to boil them for 8 to 10 minutes until they turn a bright orange color. Fresh crab claws will need to be steamed for around 15 minutes.

How many crab claws is a serving? ›

Generally, one claw per person is a good rule. If you order them for a party, you may want to order 2 or 3 pounds per person; if you're having an appetizer, count 2/3 of a pound of claws per person. This will vary with the size of the crabs and how many people you have eating crabs.

Are crab claws healthy? ›

Stone Crab Claws Are Nutrient Dense

These nutrients include various vitamins and minerals such as iron, vitamin B12, and even folate. It also contains zinc, niacin, and selenium. If you are looking for a low-calorie meal rich in protein, then crab meat is a great bet.

How do you eat crab claws without a cracker? ›

Depending on the type of crab, you may need to use different methods to split the legs open. For example, king crabs have a harder shell, which a crab cracker can easily break through. Want to know how to crack crab legs without a cracker? You can use a mallet or knife to pressure the shell and break it open.

Which are better crab legs or crab claws? ›

Though crab claws differ in texture, color, and taste, they are no less loved than their leg counterparts. Crab claws are especially ideal for diners who prefer a more savory flavor, as they are darker than leg meat—a more pinkish-brown color—and contain more fat and oil.

What part of a crab can't you eat? ›

The crab's lungs appear as feathery cones lining the side of the body. Remove them and throw them away. An old wives' tale says crab lungs are toxic, but they're actually just not digestible and taste terrible.

How do you know when crab claws are done? ›

Different Cooking Methods

You only want to serve crab when the shell is red; otherwise it's not done, and the meat will be bad. That's how to tell if your stone crab claws are cooked perfectly. You can also check when you serve the dish, as cooked crab meat should separate easily from the shell.

What sauces are good with crab? ›

10 Sauces to Enjoy With Your Dungeness Crab Legs
  • Sweet Cajun Butter. ...
  • Garlic-Herb Buttermilk Dip. ...
  • Tartar sauce. ...
  • Remoulade. ...
  • co*cktail Sauce. ...
  • Green co*cktail Sauce. ...
  • Clarified Butter. ...
  • Meyer Lemon Aioli.
Aug 25, 2020

How many crab legs per person? ›

Make sure you have enough crab legs

Our general recommendation is between one and two pounds per person. One pound per person should suffice if you have guests with mild appetites and you serving sides with your crab legs.

What is crab mustard? ›

Contrary to popular belief, the "mustard" is not fat, rather it's the crab's hepatopancreas, the organ responsible for filtering impurities from the crab's blood. Although many find its flavor distinct and delicious, it is recommended that you do not eat this since many chemical contaminants concentrate in the organ.

Do you rinse crab legs after boiling? ›

Remove the crab legs from the pot and rinse in cold water to stop them from cooking further.

How do you clean fresh crab before cooking? ›

3. How to clean and prepare crab
  1. 3.2 Remove sharp tips of legs. Place the crab you put to sleep in the freezer on the cutting board. ...
  2. 3.3 Remove belly flap. ...
  3. 3.4 Remove top shell (carapace) ...
  4. 3.7 Remove mandibles. ...
  5. 3.8 Remove gills. ...
  6. 3.9 Cut off crab claws. ...
  7. 3.11 Cut crab body into pieces. ...
  8. 3.12 Crab pieces, done!
Jul 2, 2021

Do you rinse crab? ›

Once unwanted materials are removed from the crab, it can be cleaned using water. Hold the crab under running tap water to rinse out the guts. These are the greenish brown substances found inside the crab. Keep rinsing the crab until the guts are completely removed.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. Nancy Dach

Last Updated:

Views: 5969

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. Nancy Dach

Birthday: 1993-08-23

Address: 569 Waelchi Ports, South Blainebury, LA 11589

Phone: +9958996486049

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Web surfing, Scuba diving, Mountaineering, Writing, Sailing, Dance, Blacksmithing

Introduction: My name is Prof. Nancy Dach, I am a lively, joyous, courageous, lovely, tender, charming, open person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.